The short answer
If you run a small local business, you can probably do much of your own SEO using official guides and free tools like Google Search Console. Hiring an agency or consultant can save time and bring specialist experience, but you remain responsible for their work, so vet them carefully before handing over control.
Many small business owners can handle the basics of SEO themselves without paying an agency. Google’s own guidance on whether you need an SEO states that if you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself.
Hiring help becomes worthwhile when you lack the time, technical confidence, or desire to learn the detail. The sections below set out when DIY makes sense, when to bring someone in, and how to stay in control if you do.
When doing SEO yourself makes sense
Most websites are found by Google automatically without special intervention, according to Google’s SEO Starter Guide. For a straightforward local business website, DIY SEO is often enough to cover the fundamentals.
In our view, doing it yourself works best when your website is relatively small, you can edit your own pages, and you are willing to follow Google’s official guidance steadily over time. Google notes in its SEO Starter Guide that changes can take from a few hours to several months to take effect, and recommends waiting a few weeks to assess the impact of any update.
As a starting point, it helps to read Google Search Essentials, which sets out the technical requirements, spam policies, and key best practices Google expects sites to follow. Pairing that guidance with Google Search Console lets you see how your site appears in search without paying for third-party software.
When hiring an agency or consultant makes sense
Google’s SEO Starter Guide suggests considering hiring an SEO if you are short on time or not feeling adventurous. In our view, that also applies if your website has technical problems you cannot diagnose, or if you are launching a new site and want the structure right from the start.
Hiring an SEO can save time and improve your site, as Google’s Do you need an SEO guide notes. However, Google also warns that an irresponsible SEO can damage your site and reputation, and that you remain responsible for the actions of any company you hire.
In our view, you do not have to choose between doing everything alone and signing up for ongoing support. Some business owners start with a one-off SEO audit (£450) to get a prioritised list of fixes they can carry out themselves, while others prefer ongoing monthly SEO (from £450 a month) when they would rather hand over the regular work.
Questions to ask and red flags to watch for
Before you hire anyone, Google’s Do you need an SEO guide recommends asking questions such as:
- Can they show examples of previous work and share references?
- Do they follow Google Search Essentials?
- What results do they expect, in what timeline, and how will they measure them?
- What experience do they have in your industry or local area?
- How will you communicate, and how often will they share updates?
Google also highlights several warning signs that should make you pause before signing a contract:
- Unsolicited emails or cold pitches claiming your site has urgent problems.
- Claiming a “special relationship” with Google or advertising a “priority submit”.
- Being secretive or refusing to clearly explain what they intend to do.
- Guaranteeing the number one spot on Google.
How to keep control of your website and data
Even if you hire an agency or consultant, keeping ownership of your core accounts protects your business if you ever decide to switch or take things back in-house. In our view, three habits make the biggest difference:
- Keep your domain name, website hosting, and Google Search Console account registered under your own business email rather than an agency’s account.
- Start with read-only access to Google Search Console for an initial audit, as Google recommends, and only grant editing access once you have agreed the scope of work.
- Ask for plain-English notes on every change made to your site, so you always know what was updated and why.
Sources
Where a claim depends on how Google or another company says something works, we link to their own words so you can check it.
- Do you need an SEO?, Google Search Central. Supports DIY SEO for small local businesses, responsibility for hired work, questions to ask and red flags.
- SEO Starter Guide, Google Search Central. Supports automatic discovery, when to hire help and how long changes take to show.
- Google Search Essentials, Google Search Central. Supports the core technical requirements, spam policies and best practices that govern Google Search.
- About Search Console, Google Search Console Help. Supports using Google Search Console as a free tool to monitor indexing, search traffic and alerts.
About this answer. We are an independent studio and this is our own research, experience and opinion, shared as general guidance. It is not legal, financial or other professional advice, and what works for one business may not work for another. Where the law or a regulator is involved, check the official guidance for your situation or ask a qualified adviser. Our sources are listed above.