What are the red flags when hiring an SEO agency?

Answers · More Than Normal, Canterbury

The short answer

The biggest red flags are guaranteed rankings, claims of a special relationship with Google, secrecy about the work, and promises to buy backlinks or publish pages at scale. Google warns that irresponsible SEO work can damage your site and reputation, and advises giving an SEO read-only access to Search Console.

Most SEO red flags come down to three things, namely promising outcomes no one outside Google can control, hiding what you are actually paying for, or using shortcuts that put your website at risk. Google’s guide on hiring an SEO notes that while a good SEO can improve your visibility and save you time, irresponsible work can damage both your site and your reputation.

Seven warning signs to watch for

If you see any of these in a sales email, a proposal or a discovery call, slow down and ask hard questions before signing anything.

  • Guaranteed rankings or a promise of first place. Google states that no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and its SEO Starter Guide adds that there are no secrets that automatically put a site first.
  • Claims of a “special relationship” with Google or secret metrics. Google warns against anyone claiming insider access or priority treatment, and its AI optimisation guide advises caution about any tool or service claiming access to Google’s internal ranking metrics.
  • Secrecy about what they will do. If an agency says its methods are proprietary and will not explain in plain English what changes it plans to make to your website, treat that as a warning sign. You are responsible for what goes onto your domain.
  • Buying links or “hundreds of backlinks a month”. Under Google’s spam policies, buying or selling links to manipulate rankings counts as link spam, which can result in your site dropping in search or being removed altogether.
  • Mass-producing thin or automated pages. Google’s spam policies also forbid doorway pages and scaled content abuse, including generating large volumes of low-value AI pages purely to catch search queries.
  • Asking to hold your accounts under their own name. Google’s hiring guide advises giving an SEO read-only access to Search Console rather than handing over control. In our view, your business should always own its domain, website hosting, Search Console and analytics.
  • Unsolicited “we found errors on your website” emails. In our view, cold emails that list generic automated warnings to push you into buying a fix are rarely a real audit.

What should you ask instead?

A straightforward SEO provider should be comfortable answering basic questions in writing before you pay a penny. Ask what specific work will be done each month, who will carry it out, how progress will be measured against enquiries rather than vanity keywords, and how you leave if you decide to stop.

What does a safe provider look like?

If a provider is open about what they can and cannot control, explains every change in plain English and leaves you in charge of your own accounts, you are on much safer ground. Give them read-only access to Search Console while you are starting out, agree a clear scope in writing, and avoid long tie-ins you cannot leave if the work is not helping.

Sources

Where a claim depends on how Google or another company says something works, we link to their own words so you can check it.

  1. Do You Need an SEO? Tips for Hiring an SEO, Google Search Central. Supports that no one can guarantee a number one ranking, warning signs such as secrecy or claiming a special relationship with Google, and keeping Search Console ownership.
  2. SEO Starter Guide: The Basics, Google Search Central. Supports that there are no secrets that automatically rank a site first and no guarantee a site will be indexed.
  3. Google's guide to optimizing for generative AI features on Google Search, Google Search Central. Supports caution about tools or services claiming guaranteed ranking success or access to Google's internal metrics.
  4. Spam policies for Google web search, Google Search Central. Supports that link spam, doorway pages, scaled content abuse and hidden text violate Google's spam policies and can lead to removal or lower rankings.

About this answer. We are an independent studio and this is our own research, experience and opinion, shared as general guidance. It is not legal, financial or other professional advice, and what works for one business may not work for another. Where the law or a regulator is involved, check the official guidance for your situation or ask a qualified adviser. Our sources are listed above.

Get our new answers by email

One short email a week with the answers we've published. Unsubscribe with one click.

We email you a link to confirm first. See our privacy notice.

Want help with this on your website

Tell us about your website and what you want from search, and we will say honestly what would help.

Book a discovery callGet an SEO audit

No obligation, and we reply by email.