What does an SEO audit include, and is it worth it?

Answers · More Than Normal, Canterbury

The short answer

An SEO audit is a written review of what is helping or holding back your website in Google Search, with prioritised recommendations for what to fix first. It is worth paying for if your site is not bringing enquiries or before you commit to monthly SEO, and poor value if it is only an automated tool export.

An SEO audit is a structured check of how well search engines can find, read and trust your website, ending with a prioritised list of what to fix. In our view, a good audit is written by a person looking at your actual pages and market, whereas an automated PDF exported from a software tool rarely tells you what matters.

What a good SEO audit checks

Google’s guide on hiring an SEO lists the core areas a specialist reviews, including site content and structure alongside technical advice on hosting, redirects, error pages and JavaScript. Those checks sit alongside Google Search Essentials, which sets out the technical requirements, spam policies and best practices needed for a site to appear and perform in Search.

In practice, a thorough audit for a small business usually looks at five areas:

  • Crawling and indexing. Checking whether Google can reach your key pages, whether any are blocked by robots.txt or noindex tags, and whether redirects, broken links or XML sitemaps are working cleanly.
  • Technical foundations. Reviewing mobile usability, page speed, HTTPS, hosting behaviour and whether important content relies on JavaScript that search engines struggle to render.
  • Page content and structure. Looking at your main service pages, page titles, headings, internal links and duplicate or thin pages to see whether each page clearly answers what customers search for.
  • Search Console data. Reviewing your Google Search Console indexing reports, search queries and click-through performance to spot pages that are ignored or underperforming.
  • Local visibility (where relevant). Checking how your site aligns with your Google Business Profile, location details and local search intent.

The output should be a plain-English action list ranked by impact, rather than a raw spreadsheet of warnings.

One concrete example of audit scope

As an example of how that looks in practice, our own SEO audit at More Than Normal is £450 and delivers a written report with prioritised recommendations. We review five pages in depth and up to five more briefly, covering technical and indexing checks, existing content, relevant local search and Google Business Profile. We aim to deliver within five working days of payment (allow up to ten days), and the audit does not include carrying out the fixes.

Other providers scope and price their audits differently, so always ask which pages they will actually read and whether fixes are included or quoted separately.

When is an SEO audit worth paying for?

In our view, an audit is most useful in three situations.

  • Before committing to monthly SEO. Paying for a one-off diagnosis lets you see what is actually wrong before signing up for ongoing work, and gives you a clear brief if you decide to fix things yourself or with your existing developer.
  • When a site has been live for months with few enquiries. If your business does not show up for your main services, an audit separates technical blockers (such as indexing or noindex issues) from weak or missing service pages.
  • After a website redesign. Checking redirects, page titles and indexing soon after a move helps spot problems before they linger.

When can you skip paying for one?

If you only launched your website a week ago, or you have not yet checked Google Search Console, start with the free checks first. Search Console shows whether Google can crawl and index your pages and which searches are already bringing impressions.

In our view, it is also worth being cautious of “free” or very cheap audits that turn out to be automated tool scores sent as a sales hook. A list of 200 minor warnings without plain-English priorities rarely helps a small business decide what to do on Monday morning.

Sources

Where a claim depends on how Google or another company says something works, we link to their own words so you can check it.

  1. Do You Need an SEO? Tips for Hiring an SEO, Google Search Central. Supports what SEO specialists review, including site content, structure and technical issues such as redirects, error pages and hosting.
  2. Google Search Essentials, Google Search Central. Supports the technical requirements, spam policies and best practices a website needs to be eligible and perform in Google Search.
  3. About Search Console, Google Search Console Help. Supports checking crawling, indexing and search traffic for free in Google Search Console.

About this answer. We are an independent studio and this is our own research, experience and opinion, shared as general guidance. It is not legal, financial or other professional advice, and what works for one business may not work for another. Where the law or a regulator is involved, check the official guidance for your situation or ask a qualified adviser. Our sources are listed above.

Get our new answers by email

One short email a week with the answers we've published. Unsubscribe with one click.

We email you a link to confirm first. See our privacy notice.

Want to know where your website stands

A written SEO audit shows what to fix first, in order of priority, for £450.

Get an SEO auditBook a discovery call

No obligation, and we reply by email.